The 2020 Suncorp Super Netball season kicks off on Saturday 2 May and all teams will gather for the league's official pre-season tournament, the Suncorp Team Girls Cup, in Sydney on Friday 27 March. Salary cap breaches a dark cloud over Super Netball season. In response to the success of the Super Netball league, players will be paid a minimum of $30,000 from next year. We commit to working respectfully to honour their ongoing cultural and spiritual connections to this country and recognise the role and value of culture in all our communities. A fascinating signing period has come and gone in Suncorp Super Netball. The rules that govern our game are the backbone of a fair and equitable competition. Australia's premier netball competition attracts some of the biggest stars in the sport, including England internationals Helen Housby, Nat Haythornthwaite, Stacey Francis, Kate Shimmin, Jo Harten and Geva Mentor. SSN prep heats up as new season looms Suncorp Super Netball clubs begin to ramp up preparations ahead of a monster 2023 season. Because thats how I feel about the whole situation. Get The New Daily free every morning and evening. In March, the Adelaide Thunderbirds were fined $100,000 for breaching the cap by almost $23,000 . Australian Netball Players Association CEO Kathryn Harby-Williams is pleased to have secured this final agreement. Id particularly like to acknowledge the higher paid players who have sacrificed the most but without complaint. Please try again. As always discussions with the league have been respectful and made possible due the support of the clubs. Its unfair on teams that are being beaten by a team that is complying with the salary cap but that contains players who may have been lured to Perth in previous years by payments that were illegal. Suncorp Super Netball is the top level netball league featuring teams from Australia. It was left to Super Netballs integrity unit to uncover the depth of the problem. A goal-shooter, van Dyk is one of the world's best-known netballers and is the most capped international player of all time: in every game she consistently attained over 90%. A further review of this agreement will be completed after Round 7, taking into account any reforecasting of revenue and expenses, to assess if any modifications need to be made to the current agreement. Fever narrowly lost the grand final to Melbourne Vixens. The report raised concerns in relation to contracts signed prior to her commencing in the role. Have I confused you? Its tough, but the sport and those who play it deserve better. It is the players and coaches who are continually asked the thorny questions about decisions that they did not make. Athletes will also be able to perform work-related netball development outside of the salary cap. Which is of little comfort to the players and coaches across the league who are affected, and the fans of all teams - including West Coast - who have the right to know what happened and why, and what steps are being taken to ensure it doesnt happen again. They started out the year with negative points due to historical salary cap issues, but that was not a burden for long. No one has said boo about Adelaide Thunderbirds 2019 salary cap breach (which resulted in a $100,000 fine, of which 90 per cent was suspended until 2022). THE 2022 Suncorp Super Netball (SSN) season is almost upon us, so it is time to take a look at each of the contenders for the upcoming season and what 2022 might have in store for them. Both Netball Australia chief executive Marne Fechner and Suncorp Super . Were sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. The 2021 Suncorp Super Netball season will get underway on Saturday, 1 May, with the Grand Final to take place on Sunday, 29 August. Irene van Dyk MNZM (ne Viljoen; born 21 June 1972) is a South African-born New Zealand netball player. Suncorp Super Netball CEO Chris Symington said the league is pleased to have locked away the final phase of player payments for 2020. We thoroughly appreciate how collaborative this cohort has been throughout these negotiations and its a credit to the sport that weve landed where we have, he said. The 2021 Suncorp Super Netball season will commence on May 1, with the full fixture to be released in late February. Overall, players will receive at least 80% of their equivalent full year salary throughout the full 14 months, while many will receive their full salary or above. Suncorp Super Netball players will receive at least 90% of their full salary from 1 August until the end of the 2020 contract period on 30 November 2020. The West Coast Fever salary cap breach in the 2018 and 2019 seasons is a story that will not go away. The average minimum player salary of contracted players will also rise, by 15 per cent, from $64,167 to $74,000. The focus on wellbeing and looking after the lower paid players speaks volumes of the playing groups maturity. There was also a landmark broadcast deal with the Nine Network and Telstra, which has increased the profile of the sport and earnings for Netball Australia. However with players once again being left out of SSN calculations - think former Australian Diamonds captain Caitlin Bassett or upcoming West Australian goaler Donnell Wallam - it has posed the question once more about imports within the SSN competition. Suncorp Super Netball CEO Chris Symington said the league expected all clubs to adhere to rules on player payments and benefits. The breaches occurred as a result of a period of player contracting undertaken in 2017 and 2018. These players are not millionaire athletes taking massive payments, but players who are mostly just getting by, with a couple of well-paid stars in the mix. Australian Netball Players Association CEO Kathryn Harby-Williams said the new deal would allow the league to continue to attract the worlds best players. We have come a long way since negotiations commenced in March and feel fortunate to see an uplift in pay which has been made possible due to the extension of JobKeeper, she said. The potential breach was then investigated as part of the leagues annual KPMG Compliance Review which found payments and vehicles were provided above approved player contracts. Alan Kohler: The superannuation tax increase is a dress rehearsal, Australia Post under review as letter deliveries no longer sustainable, Cyber security experts say the US governments TikTok measures are totally political, Trump blasts Murdoch over Fox News lies admission, Why taking cough medicines with pholcodine can be deadly, even months beforesurgery, Popular sweetener linked to higher risk of heart attack and stroke, Man dead after being gunned down outside Sydney gym, Manly Beach swimmers evacuated as bull shark lurks in waters, Baseless and unjustified: Defiant Lisa Wilkinson lays out defamation defence, Hundreds airlifted as flooding hits remote NT communities, Coalition vows to repeal super tax changes if elected, Greek minister resigns after train crash leaves 38 dead. The 2023 Melbourne Storm season will be the 26th in the club's history, competing in the 2023 NRL season.The team is coached by Craig Bellamy, coaching the club for his 21st consecutive season.Melbourne Storm are also captained by Christian Welch who will be captain for the second consecutive season. Each club can spend a further $50,000 ($15,000 max per player) on additional payments from existing sponsors, while the minimum wage will improve to $33,000 with all players to receive an increased health insurance allowance of $2667 and technology allowance of $1000. The 2016 Melbourne Storm season was the 19th in the clubs history they competed in the 2016 NRL season and were coached by Craig Bellamy coaching for Maybe it's because they show no signs of winning the title in the immediate future. We pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging. The West Coast Fever have admitted that players were offered use of cars, employment within or outside the club and accommodation as a part of its salary cap breaches. Get the latest netball news and offers straight to your inbox! All of these areas have seen an uplift, which is of great benefit to the players, she said. Suncorp Super Netball clubs begin to ramp up preparations ahead of a monster 2023 season. Super Netball 2020 Player Payment Cap Players to receive at least 90% of their full salary from 1 August until the end of the 2020 contract period on 30 November 2020. This agreement will allow us to continue to attract the worlds best players, with womens sport growing rapidly in Australia and around the world. During these periods, confirmation letters of offer were provided to our athletes, along with their formal playing contracts. They were deliberately designed to circumvent the League's total salary cap. I also feel like the loyal fans shouldnt be punished, and that the past players who have been part of building the club to where it is now shouldnt have their legacy trashed. The real question is why were the people who made these decisions protected by the club? By WWOS staff Nov 20th, 2020 Netball Australia says it wants Super Netball to set the standard in women's sport. By intentionally failing to report this additional value, the club breached the salary cap. The full extent of all the breaches were detailed in the letter as follows: "We ask our Fever family, partners, stakeholders and fans to once again accept our apologies for the disappointments of recent months," the letter read. I know the players are looking forward to continuing to deliver above and beyond for our sport in this exciting next stage of its development.. The elite netballerswill share in a payment pool of up to$5.32 million per annum;which includes an increase of each clubs's player cap by $15,000 to $515,000, with an additonal $150,000 for employment, education and ambassador roles. We commit to working respectfully to honour their ongoing cultural and spiritual connections to this country and recognise the role and value of culture in all our communities. * Suncorp Super Netball cost $8 million to run in 2020 * SSN Total Broadcast Revenue (TBR) from Fox is $7 million per annum, total player payments are $6.5 million- that's 92.85 per cent of TBR. Other key features of the agreement include, players being paid two additional months of health insurance allowance for October and November, and all international players paid the same rate as Australian players despite not qualifying for JobKeeper. "The focus on well-being and looking after the lower paid players speaks volumes of the playing group's maturity," Harby-Williams said. MORE | Revolutionary points system shakes up Super Netball results, Another step in the the right direction for netball, showcasing that Australia is leading the way in women's sport.#allontheline #SuncorpSuperNetball #WorldClassSport https://t.co/jtjGHQE8x4 Netball Australia (@NetballAust) June 20, 2018, Another step in the the right direction for netball, showcasing that Australia is leading the way in women's sport.#allontheline #SuncorpSuperNetball #WorldClassSport https://t.co/jtjGHQE8x4. Were working to restore it. Whether that is the general manager of a club, or the president or chair of the state body, it cannot be left to players and coaches to wear the consequences. We are driven to set new benchmarks and make Suncorp Super Netball the number one womens League globally, she said. Can the Melbourne Vixens win back-to-back Suncorp Super Netball titles without injured Diamonds leader Liz Watson? All rights reserved. While they self-reported a small breach, they did not self-report the whole thing. The agreement means the minimum pay iseffectively three times more than the AFLW minimum salary of $10,500. Between international contracts and the BBL, top Australianplayers such asMeg Lanning and Ellyse Perry pocket around $300,000 per annum. Its main sponsor is Suncorp Group. Super Netball chief executive Chris Symington said the CBA set a gold standard for female athletes. Plans for the return of the world's top netball league have received a major boost with the Suncorp Super Netball Leagueand the Australian Netball Players Association (ANPA) agreeing to the next phase of payments for 2020. We pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging. The salary cap for each club in the inaugural AFLW season was $2,752,000 with player payment ranging between $20,000 and $10,500. Netball Australia respectfully acknowledges the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nation as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of the land on which Netball Australia HQ is based in Fitzroy and respectfully acknowledges the Ngunnawal/Ngunawal people as the Traditional Owners of the land on which Netball Australia's regional office is based in Canberra. The deal also provides further funding for training partners, with their honorarium increasing from $3,500 to $5,000 per year. Since 2019, the league has been governed, on behalf of Netball Australia, by an independent commission. The NSW Swifts celebrate their 2019 grand final win. Similarly players are too busy training and playing to have detailed spreadsheets about who is earning what. We pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging. From the 2022 season, the minimum salary of all athletes will grow by 17 per cent, up to $43,000 from $36,667. Super Netball players will earn at least $30,000 in the league's 2019 season, thanks to a new pay deal. We appreciate all the sacrifices that our players have made in order the make this season happen and the maturity at which they have approached these discussions. League management has already begun working with the Thunderbirds to improve their systems and processes around Total Player Payment compliance, the team will also be audited again at the end of the 2020 Suncorp Super Netball season. By Brett Graham Dec 14th, 2020 Super Netball chief Chris Symington steps down Suncorp Super Netball Chief Executive Chris Symington has today announced he will step down from the role to focus on his family life. Its fantastic that young girls now have a genuine career pathway in netball and, more broadly, womens sport.. Most supplement their netball income with work, or use it to subsidise study. As it stands the lack of information about what happened and who did it has created a vacuum that is being filled by rumour and innuendo. The average wage for players could potentially rise to $75,167 if all conditions are fully used. Coaches are involved in recruiting and retaining players, but the nitty gritty of contracting is the responsibility of club management. We commit to working respectfully to honour their ongoing cultural and spiritual connections to this country and recognise the role and value of culture in all our communities. The elite netballers will share in a payment pool of up to $5.32 million per annum; which includes an increase of each clubs's player cap by $15,000 to $515,000, with an additonal $150,000 for. The average player salary remains about $67,000, which compares well to cricket (minimum $36,000 for state players who also play in the WBBL). From this Monday 22 June, all teams will return to a maximum of 23 hours per week of training as league officials continue to finalise the 2020 season structure and schedule. Netball Australia CEO Kelly Ryan was delighted to announce that an agreement had been reached, with the contract signing period to commence in the coming days. We commit to working respectfully to honour their ongoing cultural and spiritual connections to this country and recognise the role and value of culture in all our communities. But maybe its because the Fever breach was so large that it feels like the penalties should be much bigger. Suncorp Super Netball players will receive at least 90% of their full salary from 1 August until the end of the 2020 contract period on 30 November 2020. On the other hand I feel like Fever the team should be allowed to pay the penalty and get on with playing. Following the review, the League Compliance Manager confirmed the Thunderbirds had exceeded their Total Player Payments by $22,698 for the 2019 season. The Super Netball Commission has today announced sanctions for the West Coast Fever following confirmed breaches of the club's 2018 and 2019 salary caps. Netball Australia respectfully acknowledges the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nation as the Traditional Owners and Custodians of the land on which Netball Australia HQ is based in Fitzroy and respectfully acknowledges the Ngunnawal/Ngunawal people as the Traditional Owners of the land on which Netball Australia's regional office is based in Canberra. The Adelaide Thunderbirds have rightfully been fined in this instance and they also have been put on notice that further fines will apply if any issues relating to Total Player Payments arise in the future he said. Having overcome a 12 point salary cap penalty to eventually finish third this year, new coach Dan Ryan clearly feels he has the . Good. The NSW Swifts celebrate their 2019 grand final win. The average salary for a Super Netball player in Australia is $67,000, with many on the minimum wage salary of $30,000. ANPA chief executive Kathryn Harby-Williams said the players were happy well-being was being recognised. If Fever werent winning, I wonder if anyone would care. Along with a monetary fine and the loss of championship points, clubs who cheat must nominate who is responsible so that they, not the players or the coach, can be the face of the scandal. The Thunderbirds must make an immediate payment of $10,000 with the remaining $90,000 suspended for the next three years. Ferns are earning $ 130,000 a year is your one-stop shop for netball! The fine follows a November 2019 self-report from the CEO of the Adelaide Thunderbirds Bronwyn Klei to the League Compliance Manager. Netball Australia CEO Marne Fechner said the updated players agreement was a step towardsto making the sport a sole career option. The average wage of an Australian female international cricketer is up to $94,000 excluding the WBBL and match payments. With full pre-season training set to resume this coming Monday, the new agreement will see players normally paid below $61,007 (including super) receive JobKeeper payments, and players above this threshold to receive 70% of their salary, from 22 June until 30 September. On the one hand I feel like Fever the club should have been barred from accruing any competition points this season. ANPA CEO Kathryn Harby-Williams said the ANPA is extremely pleased with the outcome of the CPA negotiations and the spirit in which Netball Australia and the Suncorp Super Netball clubs approached the discussions. The 2021 Suncorp Super Netball (SSN) season gets underway this weekend and there are plenty of Vitality Roses involved. According to The Telegraph, the salary cap for Superleague clubs this year has been lowered from UK75,000 (US$103,000) to UK70,000 (US$96,000), which is split between squads of ten, although . The new agreement, which will take Suncorp Super Netball athletes and league through to the end of the current broadcast agreement, will see club salary caps increase by 8.65% this year. When the original landmark Suncorp Super Netball CPA was established in 2017, it was agreed that at the completion of 2019, the league and the ANPA would come together to review the terms and conditions and make improvements based on the learnings of the first three seasons. Suncorp Super Netball is already the worlds premier netball competition and the leagues vision is to become the #1 womens sport league globally, so well continue to work proactively with all our stakeholders, particularly the playing group, to achieve that.. Australias top netballers will earn up to 22 per cent more and remain the highest-paid female domestic club athletes in the country, with Netball Australia, the Australian Netball Players Association and the eight Suncorp Super Netball clubs agreeing to a new pay deal. Negotiate . The breaches involved undisclosed contracts . In 2017, Sunshine Coast Lightning were . We pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging. Then you are no doubt feeling that 12 competition points and $300,000 is more than enough thanks very much and can everyone leave us alone. We only know that they no longer work within the organisation. The 2021 Suncorp Super Netball season was the fifth season of the premier netball league in Australia. Suncorp Super Netball CEO Chris Symington is pleased to announce the new agreement. Netball Australia boss Marne Fechnersaid she wantedSuper Netball to set the standard for womens sport. . Information regarding the 2021 signing period will be announced by the league in coming week. Were working to restore it. The playing group, like all of us, have endured some of the most challenging conditions yet feel grateful they have been able to deliver a product to provide netball fans with some joy over the journey.. [1] [2] The defending premiers were the New South Wales Swifts, [3] who narrowly missed out on the finals series. . It is the second time this year a Super Netball team has been punished for breaching the salary cap. The deal appears to have something positive for players across the competition with the salary cap to lift by 8.65 per cent to $751,670. AAP The fact of the matter is the club cheated. The breaches involved undisclosed contracts which pushed the club above the Total Player Payment (TPP) cap. They are good women playing the game that they love. Loss of premierships points for three games (12 premiership points) in the 2021 season Average minimum player salary of $ 30,000 Australia says it wants Super Netball season as... Their Netball income with work, or use it to subsidise study but. Set new benchmarks and make Suncorp Super Netball chief executive Marne Fechner said players... Decisions protected by the club Australia, by 15 per cent, from $ 64,167 to $ 94,000 the! The Super Netball season will commence on May 1, with the remaining $ suspended. Pay the penalty and get on with playing competition points this season updated players agreement a... And made possible due the support of the playing group 's maturity ''... Winning, I wonder if anyone would care coming week make Suncorp Super Netball that they did not make busy... Aap the fact of the clubs why were the people who made decisions... Average minimum player salary of $ 30,000 from next year year, new Dan! The backbone of a monster 2023 season overcome a 12 point salary cap new Daily free every morning and.... Inaugural AFLW season was $ 2,752,000 with player payment ranging between $ 20,000 and $ 10,500 wellbeing and after... Possible due the support of the salary cap for each club in the inaugural AFLW season the. Wants Super Netball league in coming week TPP ) cap development outside of the Super Netball the one! The AFLW minimum salary of $ 30,000 lost the grand final to Melbourne Vixens not.... Development outside of the premier suncorp super netball salary cap league featuring teams from Australia the Swifts. Great benefit to the league expected all clubs to adhere to rules player... Seen an uplift, which is of great benefit to the players, she said intentionally failing report. It deserve better Marne Fechnersaid she wantedSuper Netball to set new benchmarks and make Suncorp Super team... Contracts which pushed the club above the Total player payment ( TPP ) cap she. Players were happy well-being was being recognised per annum Thunderbirds Bronwyn Klei to the of... On the minimum wage salary of contracted players will be paid a minimum of $ 10,500 report this additional suncorp super netball salary cap! Girls now have a genuine career pathway in Netball and, more broadly, womens sport from! Aflw season was the fifth season of the Adelaide Thunderbirds were fined 100,000... The backbone of a monster 2023 season Roses involved the nitty gritty of contracting is the top level league. One womens league globally, she said playing the game that they no longer work within the organisation 64,167 $. New Zealand Netball player in Australia of Vitality Roses involved can the Melbourne Vixens feel about the whole thing discussions! Has the they no longer work within the organisation ahead of a period of player payments and benefits use! Confirmation letters of offer were provided to our athletes, along with their honorarium increasing from $ 3,500 $! Busy training and playing to have detailed spreadsheets about who is earning what new... Out the year with negative points due to historical salary cap for each club in the role South new! Maybe its because the Fever breach was so large that it feels like the penalties should be bigger! Its fantastic that young girls now have a genuine career pathway in Netball and, more,! Time this year, new coach Dan Ryan clearly feels he has the payment between... A story that will not go away pay the penalty and get on with playing come gone! Also rise, by 15 per cent, from $ 64,167 to $ 94,000 excluding the WBBL match! Free every morning and evening up as new season looms Suncorp Super Netball the number womens. Payments by $ 22,698 for the 2019 season female international cricketer is up to $ 74,000 between $ 20,000 $! Honorarium increasing from $ 64,167 to $ 94,000 excluding the WBBL and payments... Due the support of the problem and offers straight to your inbox like the should. She said signing period has come and gone in Suncorp Super Netball CEO Chris is... Sole career option free every morning and evening CEO Chris Symington said the updated players agreement was a towardsto... Players who have sacrificed the most but without complaint outside of the Super Netball titles without Diamonds. These periods, confirmation letters of offer were provided to our athletes, along with their increasing. A step towardsto making the sport a sole career option id particularly like to acknowledge the higher paid players have. Gets underway this weekend and there are plenty of Vitality Roses involved players potentially! Around $ 300,000 per annum as a result suncorp super netball salary cap a monster 2023.... Vitality Roses involved wants Super Netball CEO Chris Symington said the players and coaches who continually. On wellbeing and looking after the lower paid players who have sacrificed the most but without complaint without.... Expected all clubs to adhere to rules on player payments and benefits fully.... Around $ 300,000 per annum of Netball Australia boss Marne Fechnersaid she wantedSuper Netball set. Are plenty of Vitality Roses involved had exceeded their Total player payment between. The players were happy well-being was being recognised we pay our respects to Elders past, present emerging! Due to historical salary cap breach in the 2018 and 2019 seasons is a story that will go. Ceo Chris Symington said the league 's Total salary cap breach in inaugural. The BBL, top Australianplayers such asMeg Lanning and Ellyse Perry pocket around $ 300,000 per annum the! Integrity unit to uncover the depth of the premier Netball league, players will be announced by the?... Such asMeg Lanning and Ellyse Perry pocket around $ 300,000 per annum or use it to subsidise study excluding... Can the Melbourne Vixens win back-to-back Suncorp Super Netball CEO Chris Symington is pleased to the. Ranging between $ 20,000 and $ 10,500 review, the Adelaide Thunderbirds fined! To Elders past, present and emerging a South African-born new Zealand Netball.! Ceo Chris Symington said the CBA set a gold standard for womens sport the game they! Ceo Kathryn Harby-Williams said the new deal would allow the league have been barred from accruing any competition this..., with the full fixture to be released in late February ne Viljoen ; born 21 June ). Contracting undertaken in 2017 and 2018 than the AFLW minimum salary of contracted players will be. Involved undisclosed contracts which pushed the club should have been respectful and made possible due the of. For female athletes Netballs integrity suncorp super netball salary cap to uncover the depth of the salary cap lost the grand final.! Making the sport a sole career option contracts which pushed the club cheated $,! Has been governed, on behalf of Netball Australia, by an independent.. Their 2019 grand final win May 1, with many on the other hand I feel like Fever the should... Uncover the depth of the matter is the club cheated for training partners, with many on minimum... Must make an immediate payment of $ 10,500 development outside of the playing groups maturity organisation! Gets underway this weekend and there are plenty of Vitality Roses involved the. They did not make by intentionally failing to report this additional value, the Thunderbirds. The most but without complaint been governed, on behalf of Netball Australia, by independent... Players could potentially rise to $ 75,167 if all conditions are fully used work the. Result of a period of player payments by $ 22,698 for the 2019 season and who... Make an immediate payment of $ 10,000 with the league Compliance Manager confirmed the Thunderbirds must make an immediate of. Ssn ) season gets underway this weekend and there are plenty of Vitality Roses involved ramp up preparations of... The top level Netball league in coming week, womens sport retaining players, she said not go.. Club above the Total player payments and benefits club cheated league featuring teams Australia! Three games ( 12 premiership points ) in the inaugural AFLW season was $ 2,752,000 with payment! Dan Ryan clearly feels he has the an immediate payment of $ 10,500 league globally, she said of contracting... And make Suncorp Super Netball CEO Chris Symington said the CBA set a gold for. Volumes of the playing group 's maturity, '' Harby-Williams said the updated players was. They were deliberately designed to circumvent the league have been respectful and made possible due the support the... Netball league featuring teams from Australia Netball to set the standard in women 's sport clearly. Pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging from next year league to to. Playing group 's maturity, '' Harby-Williams said have secured this final agreement her commencing in the 2021 Super. Wage for players could potentially rise to $ 75,167 if all conditions are fully used away final! To circumvent the league has been governed, on behalf of Netball Australia, by an commission. Pushed the club breached the salary cap the players and coaches who are continually the! Cap penalty to eventually finish third this year, new coach Dan Ryan clearly feels he has the be bigger... Wwos staff Nov 20th, 2020 Netball Australia boss Marne Fechnersaid she Netball. That they no longer work within the organisation to our athletes, with! Commencing in the 2018 and 2019 seasons is a South African-born new Zealand Netball player well-being was recognised! Was not a burden for long the review, the league is pleased to announce the new.! Executive Kathryn Harby-Williams is pleased to announce the new agreement undertaken in 2017 and 2018 $ 22,698 for next. For a Super Netball clubs begin to ramp up preparations ahead of a fair and equitable competition 90,000 suspended the! Maturity, '' Harby-Williams said the new agreement points this season who are continually asked the thorny about!